AlbumsDecember 17, 201718,785 views

Glassjaw Material Control

Material Control
01. New White Extremity 02. Shira 03. 11 Days 04. Golgotha 05. Pretty Hell 06. Bastille Day 07. Pompeii 08. Bibleland 09. Closer 10. My Conscience Weighs A Ton 11. Material Control 12. Cut And Run
2017 self-released
Our score 6


When Glassjaw burst onto the scene in 2000 with their debut full-length, Everything You Ever Wanted To Know About Silence, the band walked a fine line of hardcore and emo. Led by vocalist Daryl Palumbo's intense screams and oddly accentuated singing, the record fluctuated between razor sharp aggression and delicate melody; fits of rage turned into tender singing and back again. It was on their 2002 follow-up Worship And Tribute that the group's songwriting matured into a more fluid blend of the contradicting sounds, utilizing Palumbo's penchant for catchy melodies and guitar player Justin Beck's noisy, effect-laden riffs to achieve a fuller, more realized sound. Although Glassjaw would regularly hint at work-in-progress on their third album, the group wouldn't be heard from again for the next nine years when in 2011 they released a pair of EPs, the first of which, Our Color Green, would contain some of their strongest material to date. Tracks like "All Good Junkies Go To Heaven" and "You Think You're (John Fucking Lennon)" further blurred the lines between the heavy and the mellow, the hooks and the noisy chaos complementing rather than contrasting each other. But with the short run time of the EPs, Glassjaw wasn't able to capture the same ebb and flow motion that had made their full-length albums so endearing. Unfortunately, that isn't to be found on Material Control either. The band picks up sonically right where they left off six years ago. Punchy, overdriven bass lines fuel the groove to Beck and Palumbo's signature stylings, but most of the material presented sounds like fragments of songs and unfinished ideas mashed together. The record never achieves cohesiveness, neither in nor amongst its songs. Opener "New White Extremity," one of the strongest of the batch, finds new band members Bill Rymer of Dillinger Escape Plan, and Travis Sykes anchoring chaotic, clamorous riffs on drums and bass, respectively. Sykes plays complex, bouncy lines that lend direction to the sometimes seemingly compass-less bouts of noise, carving out room for Palumbo's wails and moans. But throughout most of Material Control, the vocalist struggles to find that space. With an often overbearing, claustrophobic production showcasing Beck's turbulent, in your face playing, Palumbo is rendered hook-less and buried beneath the wall of sound. He tries to overcome this in "Shira" and "My Conscious Weighs A Ton" with the addition of backing "ooh's" that sound out of place amongst the rawness of the album. The vocalist is again lost in "Citizen," a track that sounds like every member of the band is playing a different song, with Palumbo wrestling to tie it all together. "Strange Hours," another highlight, with its dreamy spaciness, is taken right out of the post-2005 Deftones playbook. The pulsing bass line and twangy chords hang back enough to let Palumbo finally stretch out his vocals a bit. However, unlike a similar Glassjaw track like "Must've Run All Day" (off Worship And Tribute), it meanders through its four minutes searching for a next part that never comes. It's when Glassjaw is at their loudest that they are also at their most forgettable on Material Control. "Pompeii" sounds like the perfect lead up to a missing ending piece, while "Golgotha" jumps between patched together riffs, uncomfortably shifting around half-baked ideas. The guitars trudge through a cacophonous mess, never quite settling into the strength exhibited by Glassjaw's heavier past. At this point in their career, Glassjaw is essentially Beck and Palumbo's band with rotating members filling in as needed. With neither of the key songwriters working at their best, they are left sounding like a watered down version of their past selves. Bottom Line: Material Control isn't a bad record; there are moments are reminiscent of what made Glassjaw great in the early 2000's and the individual performances by the musicians are top tier. However, for most of its duration, the band seems lost and unfocused. The songs on Material Control just don't stand up to the expectations Glassjaw has set.


Post Comment
anonymous 12/18/2017 8:23:12 AM

Everyone should just skip Glassjaw altogether and listen to Sons of Abraham.

anonymous 12/18/2017 9:12:40 AM

I'm a big GJ fan, this was a tough listen. With a lot of their music it takes a couple times for it to click, but this to me just doesn't come together.

anonymous 12/18/2017 10:44:09 AM

Yeah considering it took 15 years to come out I think this kinda sucked. What's with the production? Can barely hear the vocals on some tracks.

anonymous 12/18/2017 12:33:32 PM

Justin did all of the bass on the recording you dumb sheetrocker.

anonymous 12/18/2017 4:27:54 PM

I thoroughly enjoy this album - exceeded the expectations that I had before listening. Good groove and didn't agree with your review whatsoever. If you like Glassjaw, give it a listen. The only thing you shouldn't do if you like Glassjaw is see them live - they suck live.

anonymous 12/18/2017 7:00:35 PM

Sounds like crap. After 4 songs I said forget it and started listening to TWICE Heart Shaker

anonymous 12/19/2017 9:42:58 AM

doesn't stand up to the sheetrock glassjaw has set? it's been years, you melvin, just what were you expecting?

fourthgradecocktease 12/19/2017 12:14:13 PM

I love glassjaw and thought this was going to suck, turned out to be a cool surprise.

fourthgradecocktease 12/19/2017 12:17:52 PM

Also, post-2005 Deftones? Does Pony not exist in your world or what?

Ryaninstereo_ 12/21/2017 7:08:16 AM

Pretty terrible review ,guy. You should be embarrassed.

anonymous 12/21/2017 11:37:55 AM

"Everyone should just skip Glassjaw altogether and listen to Sons of Abraham." Nah band was shit

anonymous 12/25/2017 9:27:28 PM

Not having Ross Robinson led to the downfall of this album. It all just sounds like the same song and there is no progression over the course of the record.

anonymous 12/29/2017 5:54:00 AM

this is a joke of a review, this site cannot be taken seriously for any music reviews, shocked that was allowed to be posted

anonymous 12/29/2017 5:07:08 PM

I'm not much of a fan of this record either. But come on dude did you actually listen. Your critique of "citizen" is laughable.

anonymous 1/2/2018 4:57:11 PM

I love when people write music reviews, yet they lack the ability to listen.

anonymous 1/5/2018 5:26:23 AM

"jumps between patched together riffs, uncomfortably shifting around half-baked ideas. The guitars trudge through a cacophonous mess, never quite settling " LOL this describes how I've always felt about Glassjaw.

anonymous 1/14/2018 10:47:11 AM

saw them with the used, they sounded like fart

anonymous 2/12/2018 10:12:37 AM

Loved the first two albums and this article is accurate with how I felt about Material Control. An overhyped album that completely lacked what their two previous albums did. I can't help but feel that those saying they don't agree or "this is bad" are just hypnotized fans. I gave the album a number of listens, but nothing stuck. In the end it sounded like a sour GJ attempt that was influenced by Deftones.

anonymous 3/7/2018 5:01:25 AM

Too much artsy noise for my taste. I bought shira so there's that.

anonymous 3/20/2018 10:48:11 AM

Call your local grocery stores everyone, local stores now sell STD kits. Thank those brave employees who came forward sharing they will not even disclose having a STD prior to f*cking you.

fedisM 6/20/2018 9:21:58 PM

1. Glassjaw was groundbreaking during class of 2002. You cant sell the same Honda Accord that they released in 2002. 2. Ross Robinson could have probably pulled it off. But hey dropped Ross, its like dropping Steve Jobs from Apple and never hiring him back. Let this be a lesson to all you noobs.

fedism 6/30/2018 3:52:56 PM

3. This album grew on me. Better than EYWTKAS

lurkcity 6/7/2022 5:43:22 PM

fourthgradecocktease 12/19/2017 12:14:13 PM I love glassjaw and thought this was going to suck, turned out to be a cool surprise. colin is a straight up idiot wanna be fantano / matt pinfield.